March 1, 2024


Home living innovation

Perilous, Illegal & Extra! Chip Gaines’ Sued Over Botched Home Renovation

Chip Gaines still left a job website in a Fixer Higher point out, has learned!

A customer filed fit in opposition to the actuality Tv set star in 2012 after he remaining her residence in the middle of a task, declaring he was negligent in his renovations and her residence was unlivable.

She reported that she accepted Gaines’ $118,255 bid in June 2011 for “converting the connected garage into a bedroom and including a carport.” But as a substitute, she ended up spending $139,611.50 for incomplete renovations.

Browse The Courtroom Docs

She claimed that Gaines, 41, and Magnolia, “did not acquire the essential strategies for the development of the bedroom addition. As a result of the failure to draft ample options and Defendants’ deficiency of competency in building, the bedroom ground was misconstructed [sic],” producing it a “significant tripping hazard.”

The customer also claimed that Magnolia agreed to develop a porch and lengthen her roof, but “despite representations that the roof and porch would be constructed in a fantastic and workmanlike fashion, the roof leaks.” She afterwards revised her match to contain that her hot water heater broke for the reason that of Gaines’ carelessness, and she had to pay back to swap it.

She also described that they “failed to acquire the needed permits,” exclusively for a shed. The Town of Waco later manufactured her take out their add-on for an extra cost of $850.

Then, she alleged that Magnolia was intended to pay back all of the subcontractors on the project, but they did not. She documented that a lien was filed in opposition to her for $1,348.63 for components and she experienced to retain the services of a law firm for the issue.

“Defendants represented to Plaintiff [redacted] that they would give her a credit for monies she paid instantly to subcontractors,” the documents ongoing. “Plaintiff [redacted] compensated a total of $1,149.38 for landscaping, a dog doorway, and the sprinkler technique which as not credited to her.”

Finally, she claimed the renovations were being not performed in a timely manner, as “Defendants unsuccessful to fulfill any of the four completion dates established by Defendants.”

“After various revisions of the completion day, Defendants took their very last payment on April 6, 2012, in the quantity of $10,000.00, and abandoned do the job in June of 2012, around just one year just after starting the projects,” the documents examine. “On quite a few instances Plaintiff reminded Defendants of the deleterious outcomes of the delays on her professional medical disorders and standard properly-staying.”

Gaines denied her allegations, saying that “Plaintiff repeatedly designed variations to the agreed designs and/or interfered with Defendants’ makes an attempt to tender efficiency under the contract. Also, Plaintiff refused to make ultimate payment and refused to allow Defendants from re-getting into the job website to full the challenge.” He also claimed he ought to not be named in the fit, as the deal “did not impose any obligations” on him.

He claimed that she permitted of all of the function before they finished it, and has no proper to complain. He additional that “Plaintiff recognized that the lose would have to have town approval which Defendants could not guarantee” as very well.

He also said in his counterclaims that she “failed to pay out for all of the labor and materials she contracted for and refused to enable Defendant Magnolia to finish development on the project” and that she “gave directives to subcontractors or other employees on the work site.”

Eventually, he explained that “Defendant Magnolia incurred expenditures of $170,309.36 on the task to renovate Plaintiff’s residence. Plaintiff compensated Defendant Magnolia only $139,611.50.”

Just after a lengthy struggle, the scenario was dismissed with out prejudice on July 31, 2014. The client claimed that all of her statements were settled and Gaines dropped his countersuit.

Remain with Radar for the most recent on Gaines’ authorized woes.

We fork out for juicy information! Do you have a tale for Email us at, or call us at (866) ON-RADAR (667-2327) any time, working day or night.